Oh boy, some more Reacher talk coming your way. I am going to try and refrain from my usual long winded recap of my Reacher problem, but if you are interested, hit this link and read about it in reverse order.
I watched the last episode of season two a week and a half ago and it left a sour taste in my mouth. Last year’s Season 1 show, like any book to film transfer, changed some things, but it still felt like a very true representation of the book and character. Season 2, in my opinion, strayed a bit too far from the Jack Reacher ethos. The setting was changed from LA to New York, but this wasn’t an issue because Atlantic City worked for the Las Vegas location in the book.
My main problem with the adaptation came from the what I felt was a lot more bang bang shoot ’em up that I don’t remember from the book. Like they decided to increase the gun play to cater to American’s love of guns. Also, the Jack Reacher I know is an expert shot from my memory, usually a couple trigger pulls handles it. This series seemed to have a lot of gun battles where I’d swear both sides were firing enough times that the bangs were so many that it was way more than any gun could hold. And WTF, a car chase scene, this Jason Bourne stuff, not Reacher.
The big kicker for me was the final recuse of the last two reaming members of their old Army unit, the Special Investigators of the 110th, by Reacher & Neagley. They called in some reinforcements, where in the book these two do the job just fine on their own. Also this created a huge gun fight in a dark building with a fusillade bullets and it is a wonder how the good guy didn’t take each other out.
I’m not the only one who didn’t particularly like season two, go read some IMDB reviews and there are a lot of 3/10 ratings which probably come from the book readers like me. The few 10/10 ratings in there are probably from the non-book readers.
I probably won’t rewatch this season like I did for the first, I’ll will probably reread the book though, just to cleanse my palate. The show wasn’t all bad and the one thing I have to give props to the producers for was one little throw off line. Reacher is famous for checking into hotels under an assumed name, usually a New York Yankee second-string shortstop. He does that here, and when our big bad guy, probably a native New Yorker hears that name he recognizes it. Neagley, Reacher’s female compatriot, checks in using the name Sarah Conner of Terminator fame, but our evil bad guy doesn’t know that one, he says, “Never heard of her.” The actor playing to bad guy was Robert Patrick who played the T-1000 in the second Terminator movie.